The Protein Leverage Hypothesis—Could Poor Diets Be Driven by a Lack of Protein?

0 0
Read Time:6 Minute, 32 Second

Story at a glance…

  • “Gateway foods” like candy, frozen desserts and frozen pizzas have been shown in adolescents to further drive the consumption of ultra-processed foods.

  • A vicious cycle emerges from new research that shows the underconsumption of protein leads to higher consumption of ultra-processed foods.

  • Ultra-processed foods are engineered to be as addictive as possible—as addictive as tobacco smoking, recent research has shown.

 

Without sufficient protein intake, the body tends to overeat carbs and fats in order to scavenge up the deficit, a new study showed.

In another study, ultra-processed foods like candy were found to act like gateway drugs towards the consumption of more ultra-processed foods.

When the findings are put together a vicious cycle emerges, one in which the emphasis on a carb and sugar-rich breakfast among children in the West—picture toast with jam, sugary cereal with milk, or waffles with syrup and a glass of orange juice—triggers the hunt for more protein, which facilitates the eating of more carbs that in turn act as gateway foods to further poor choices.

“Fundamental disagreement exists over the drivers and mechanisms underlying the obesity epidemic,” open the authors of a new paper published in Obesity. “The protein leverage hypothesis (PLH) proposes that in macro-nutritionally imbalanced food environments, strong human regulation of protein intake drives energy overconsumption and obesity (“protein leverage”) on protein-dilute highly processed diets”.

In their study, lead author Amanda Grech et al. looked at dietary data from the Australian National Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey to challenge a pair of foundational predictions under the PLH. Both predictions were confirmed in a population setting; the mean protein intake was 18.4%, and energy intake decreased with increasing energy from protein.

They detail in the discussions section that the effect of protein leverage on eating patterns has been confirmed before in randomized controlled trials in metabolic wards, but that their work confirmed it in observational population data, giving the overall hypothesis a strong confidence level.

A thorough body of evidence has shown that protein is the most satiating macronutrient. The analysis of Gretch et al. implicates highly processed discretionary foods as a likely cause of protein dilution, which opens the discussion to the effect of these as gateway foods.

“Through increasing the likelihood of eating other ultra-processed foods, gateway foods could have the effect of drawing people more deeply into processed food diets, so further diluting dietary protein and engaging protein leverage,” said co-author David Raubenheimer, Charles Perkins Centre, University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.

“Gateway foods would, in other words, amplify protein leverage – they directly cause protein dilution and energy overconsumption, and also increase the prevalence in the diet of other ultra-processed foods hence causing further protein dilution and energy overconsumption”.

PICTURED: A researcher at Virginia Tech studies food addiction. PC: Clayton Metz for Virginia Tech. Released.

Gateway drugs

Highly-processed and refined foods are known now to be engineered to be as addictive as possible. Roasted peanuts, despite containing peanut oil naturally, aren’t roasted in peanut oil to improve shelf life, but rather to bypass the normal human reactions of satiety. As a test, see how many raw, unblanched, unsalted peanuts you can eat before the thought of eating more becomes repellent, compared with salted and roasted peanuts.

This was recently explored in a debate article in the journal Addiction.

Dr. Alex DiFeliceantonio, associate director of the Center for Health Behaviors Research at the Fralin Biomedical Research Institute at Virginia Tech, and Ashley N. Gearhardt, a psychology professor at the University of Michigan, analyzed whether highly processed foods — such as sugary soft drinks, baked goods, chips, burgers, and fries — can be considered addictive by comparing their properties to those of tobacco.

They concluded on November 9th that highly processed foods share the addictive characteristics of tobacco because they cause compulsive use; have psychoactive, or mood-altering, effects on the brain; and are highly reinforcing.

“The ability of highly processed foods to rapidly deliver unnaturally high doses of refined carbohydrates and fat appears key to their addictive potential,” DiFeliceantonio said.

“Minimally processed, nourishing foods, such as fruits and vegetables, do not meet these addiction criteria,” Gearhardt noted.

With this in mind, what evidence is there that these foods can have gateway effects?

Gateway foods

Ultra-processed foods such as bread, cereals, desserts, sodas, and processed meats comprise more than 60% of the calories Americans eat each day.

Lead researcher of a new study on gateway foods is 16-year-old Maria Balhara, a student at Broward College and Cooper High School at the same time. In studying her peers, she discovered that certain key foods led to increased consumption of other ultra-processed foods, while the decrease in these key foods led to a relevant decrease respectively.

“Ultra-processed foods are designed to be hyper-palatable, or engineered to be as addictive as possible,” said Balhara. “They’re also cheap and convenient, which makes them hard to resist. Most people are eating too many of these foods without realizing it”.

Balhara gathered data on how frequently adolescents consumed 12 ultra-processed food products during the previous 8 weeks. Ultra-processed foods included prepackaged cookies, candy, chips, chocolate, energy drinks, frozen desserts, soda, store-bought pastries, store-bought smoothies, syrup-sweetened coffee or tea, white bread, and processed meat.

The study included 315 teens, ages 13-19 recruited from 12 high schools in South Florida between February and April 2022, and showed how candy, prepackaged pastries, and frozen desserts were found to act as a possible gateway food to drive increased (or decreased) consumption of other processed food products. Teenagers who changed their consumption of these “gateway” foods were more likely to change their consumption of all other ultra-processed foods as well.

Associated increases in the consumption of other ultra-processed foods were highest in candy (31%) followed by frozen pastries (12%) and frozen desserts (11%).

The fact that all the study participants were adolescents is considered a limitation. Adolescents are, however, a very vulnerable population for the consumption of ultra-processed foods due to the ability to circumvent, for the first time, potential restrictions in place by parents. They are also subjected to earlier school start times than children, giving them less time to prepare or have prepared for them, protein-rich breakfast foods like eggs or bacon.

In this way, the limitation to one of the most at-risk groups potentially clarifies the effect further. It’s also noteworthy considering the PLH that processed meats were not ranked as one of the gateway foods, likely due to their protein content.

“I think it’s important to note that the foods that were found to be gateway foods (frozen desserts, pastries, and candies) all have virtually no protein even though they are very high in energy,” Dr. Gretch, also at the Univ. of New South Wales, tells WaL. “This would create a vicious cycle, requiring larger portions of UPF to make up the protein deficit from poor snack choices earlier in the day”. WaL

PICTURED ABOVE: Consumed often for breakfast and containing no protein, sugary highly-processed cereals like these could act as “gateway foods,” towards the increased consumption of poor foods later in the day.

Continue exploring this topic — Processed Foods — Seed Oils Are Probably the Reason Behind Decades of Heart Disease Not Butter, Cheese, or Meat

Continue exploring this topic — Obesity — While Trying to Lose Weight More Protein Led to Healthier Overall Diets

Continue exploring this topic — Childhood — Tufts University Hopes to Take Meat Away from School Children

Happy
Happy
0 %
Sad
Sad
0 %
Excited
Excited
0 %
Sleepy
Sleepy
0 %
Angry
Angry
0 %
Surprise
Surprise
0 %

The Sunday Catchup provides all the week's stories, so you never start the week uninformed

Average Rating

5 Star
0%
4 Star
0%
3 Star
0%
2 Star
0%
1 Star
0%

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *